Saturday, January 28, 2012

Peer Response Entry 2 (Week 2)

I find myself really gravitating towards April's work. There is always something interesting to read and I get sucked in, then find something that I just HAVE to post about. Her original post can be found here: http://aprilantoniou.blogspot.com/2012/01/blue-in-red-state.html
April,
I loved the Blue in a Red State idea. This whole piece was the epitome of what Davidson was talking about "what makes you you." My favorite part was the : "Everyone went stiff. The fire crackled and spit in disdain while the crickets chirped like a group of frantic old gossiping knitters: “Did you hear that?” “Gasp!” “Oh my..." Crickets definitely seem like that when everything is quiet. I also liked the end. The idea of the "maybe I can learn to love purple" took me a minute actually, but then I laughed to myself realizing that you meant that there were good things to both the red and blue states and therefore you could maybe merge the two. That was pretty creative.
However, a question I have for you is where do you live? Because near my house, there is a Whole Foods, a Trader Joe's (a couple actually)and I believe a Jack in the Box. 
And finally, you are right when you said that the beginning of the piece is a little weak. It seems as though you start with a lot of telling about yourself. Maybe if you showed how you were born and raised in California, you could say:
"With my hair as blond as the grains of sand and my eyes as blue as the crystal Pacific, my body was the beach. I breathed sushi. The last of the Valley Girl breed, I believed everyone came to Hollywood seeking the fame, fortune and glamor she promised. Waitresses were never waitresses-but rather actresses. Customer Service Reps were recording artists. And everyone had their own scandalous celebrity story to leak. I, the insider, no impostor or visiting tourist to the world of pain and regret, silently smirked at the foolhardy aspirations of the many immigrants."
Or something like that. 

1 comment:

  1. Boy am I gald you like reading my stuff because you always have very useful input. I live in Newnan, which you would think would have all that stuff. More importantly, where do YOU live?!? Because I MUST make a trip to all those places!!

    I LOVE your ideas on how I can fix the opening, the way you phrase it make me PARt of California and I love the feeling you get form reading it. I am going ot work on revising it and who knows, this could be a revision that ends up in my final portfolio. I like the idea of taking something that sparked me to take this class and transforming it into something much better over the course of the semester.

    As always, thank you so much for taking the time to read and respond with so much substance. You help me a great deal :)

    ReplyDelete